When Tribalism Becomes Representation

An article on ethnicity, identity, representation and the politics of double standards.

For a long time, I have lived with the conviction that our politics in Kenya deserves to move away from ethnic considerations. I have always imagined a country where people elect leaders because of their ideas, integrity, leadership abilities, development records and vision for the nation. I have imagined a Kenya where a person's tribe is as insignificant as the colour of their shoes when it comes to deciding who should occupy a political office. Unfortunately, this is not the Kenya we have built.

We have become so accustomed to looking at politics through ethnic lenses that we sometimes struggle to imagine an election without bringing our tribal identities into the conversation. We may spend an entire year identifying ourselves as Kenyans. We sing the national anthem, celebrate our national holidays, wave the national flag and proudly introduce ourselves as citizens of one country. However, when election season arrives, something interesting happens. The Kenyan identity we have been nurturing suddenly takes a back seat, and our ethnic identities come to the forefront.

We become Kikuyus, Luos, Luhyas, Kalenjins, Maasais, Kambas and members of other communities. Our political conversations change. Instead of asking which candidate has the best ideas, we begin asking which community the candidate belongs to. Instead of evaluating leadership on its merits, we start calculating how much political power our community stands to gain or lose. A person who dares to support a candidate from another community may be branded a traitor, someone who has lost direction or, as we commonly put it, someone who has been bewitched politically. In some circles, supporting a candidate outside one's ethnic community is almost like committing an offence against one's own people.

This is the political culture I have wished we could overcome. I have often wondered why we cannot simply look at one another as Kenyans and make political decisions without consulting our tribal backgrounds. Why should my neighbour's tribe determine whether I consider him suitable for leadership? Why should someone who shares my language automatically become more deserving of my vote than someone whose language I do not understand?

I have also observed that when people from other nations examine our voting patterns, they sometimes describe us as tribal. The implication is that we have failed to mature politically because we continue to organize our political loyalties around ethnic identities. I have not always disagreed with this observation. After all, if we claim to be one nation but repeatedly vote as though we are several competing nations, what other conclusion should an observer draw?

However, something caught my attention during the recently concluded 2026 midterm elections in the United States. It made me reconsider some of the assumptions I had held about ethnic politics. I began to wonder whether what we condemn as tribal politics in Africa sometimes exists elsewhere under more acceptable names.

Following the American midterm elections, the media highlighted several historic victories. We heard about the first Black woman elected governor, the first Native American woman elected governor, the first Muslim elected to the United States Senate, and other candidates who had broken representation barriers. Keisha Lance Bottoms made history in Georgia, Deb Haaland in New Mexico, and Abdul El-Sayed in Michigan. Peggy Flanagan also made history as the first Native American woman elected to the Senate. These were significant political milestones that attracted considerable attention.

What particularly caught my attention was the way these victories were presented and celebrated. We heard about Black winners, Native American winners, Muslim winners, women winners and Black women winners. The descriptions were not necessarily about the policies these individuals intended to implement, their economic plans or their leadership philosophies. Much of the attention was directed towards the identities they represented and the historical barriers their victories had broken. I found myself asking a rather uncomfortable question: If we celebrate political victories by identifying the ethnic, racial, religious or gender backgrounds of candidates in America, why do we condemn Kenyans when they discuss political victories through the identities of their communities?

Before anyone misunderstands me, I am not suggesting that racial identity, religion, gender and ethnicity are exactly the same thing. They have different histories, experiences and social implications. Neither am I suggesting that the United States has the same ethnic dynamics as Kenya. However, I see a common thread worth examining: the tendency to understand political representation through group identity.

Consider the difference in the language we use. In Kenya, when a community celebrates having one of its own elected to a powerful political position, the celebration may be described as tribalism. In America, when a Black woman becomes the first Black woman governor, the achievement is described as a historic breakthrough for representation. When a Native American woman wins an election, her victory is celebrated as an important milestone for Indigenous representation. When a Muslim candidate enters the Senate, the occasion is presented as a breakthrough for religious representation. Could it be that we sometimes judge similar human tendencies differently depending on the political and social language surrounding them?

Perhaps we have become so comfortable with certain descriptions that we no longer recognize the similarities beneath them. The word tribalism carries a negative connotation. It immediately suggests division, prejudice, exclusion and backwardness. On the other hand, words such as diversity, inclusion, representation and empowerment generally carry positive connotations. Yet all these conversations can involve the question of which groups are represented in positions of power. I think this is where we need to pause and examine ourselves.

There is nothing inherently wrong with celebrating the election of someone from a historically underrepresented community. In fact, representation can be important. A society in which certain communities have historically been excluded from leadership has legitimate reasons to celebrate the removal of barriers. It is equally understandable that women may celebrate the election of more women into positions that were previously dominated by men. Such victories can inspire people who previously believed that certain positions were beyond their reach. But there is a difference between celebrating representation and making identity the primary qualification for leadership.

A Black person does not automatically become a good leader because they are Black. A woman does not automatically become a capable administrator because she is a woman. A Muslim does not automatically become an excellent representative because they belong to the Muslim faith. Similarly, a Kikuyu, Luo, Luhya or Kalenjin does not automatically become the best political choice simply because they belong to one's community. This is the distinction I believe we must learn to appreciate. Identity may explain the historical significance of a political victory, but it should not replace the examination of a leader's ability to serve.

There is another interesting dimension to this discussion. When a minority group gains representation, the achievement is often viewed as progress towards inclusion. Yet when a Kenyan ethnic community seeks political representation, the conversation can quickly turn into an accusation of tribalism. Could the difference sometimes be that one society has developed a more acceptable vocabulary for discussing group identity while another has not?

I am not arguing that America has overcome identity politics. Far from it. Nor am I suggesting that the American election results prove that voters chose candidates primarily because of their racial, religious or gender identities. Voters have multiple reasons for supporting candidates, including party affiliation, policy positions, economic concerns and personal records. The fact that the media highlights a candidate's identity does not necessarily tell us why voters elected that candidate. Nevertheless, the prominence given to these identities tells us something about the continuing importance of group representation in modern politics.

Perhaps our problem in Kenya is not simply that we recognize our ethnic identities. Our problem is what we sometimes do with those identities. We can use them to preserve our cultures, celebrate our heritage and appreciate the diversity that makes our country what it is. However, when we turn them into political boundaries, we create divisions that make it difficult for us to hold leaders accountable.

A politician who enjoys unquestionable support from a particular community may discover that accountability is less important than ethnic loyalty. People may overlook corruption, incompetence, broken promises and poor leadership because they fear that criticizing their political representative will weaken their community's position. In such circumstances, the politician is no longer required to earn the confidence of the people through performance. Belonging to the right community becomes a political shield. This is dangerous because democracy is supposed to give citizens the power to choose and question their leaders. When our political loyalty becomes a family inheritance or an ethnic obligation, we surrender part of that power.

I would therefore like to see us move beyond the simplistic argument that recognizing group identity is always wrong. We need to ask more important questions. Are we celebrating diversity while maintaining equal standards of leadership? Are we interested in representation because we want every community to have a voice, or because we want our own people to control political power? Do we celebrate a candidate's identity and then become equally interested in examining what that candidate can deliver? These questions should not be reserved for Kenyans. They are relevant to every society that practices democracy.

The American midterm elections have given me another perspective on something I have long thought about. Perhaps identity politics is not an exclusively African problem, and perhaps we should be careful when we assume that our political challenges are unique to developing nations. Different societies have different histories, different forms of discrimination and different ways of organizing political identities. But the human desire to see one's group represented in positions of power is not confined to one continent.

I still believe that Kenya should strive towards a politics that places national interests above ethnic loyalties. However, I also recognize that we cannot build such a political culture by pretending that group identities do not exist. We must first understand them, appreciate their historical significance and learn how to prevent them from becoming instruments of exclusion.

Ultimately, I would like to live in a country where a Kikuyu can confidently vote for a Luo, a Luo can enthusiastically support a Kalenjin, a Kalenjin can elect a Luhya, and a Luhya can trust a Maasai with national leadership. Not because their ethnic identities have disappeared, but because their individual abilities, character and commitment to the country have become more important than their ancestral backgrounds.

Perhaps the real question is not whether we should recognize the identities of those who seek political office. It is whether those identities should determine the standards by which we judge them. If we condemn tribal politics in Kenya but celebrate identity-based political milestones elsewhere, are we applying the same standards, or have we simply given similar human tendencies different names? That is a question worth thinking about.

Previous Post Next Post